Licence to Pils, Pilsner

A Pilsner all-grain kit from The Homebrew Shop. A boil-over sprayed wort round the garage, and in November we opened the fermenter to discover suspended yeast and mould. A brew we’d rather forget!

Method
All-grain
Status
Ruined
Started

The numbers

Original gravity
1.044
Final gravity
1.005
ABV
5.1%
Attenuation
89%
Batch size
19.5L
Per 100ml, estimated
40kcal

ABV and attenuation come from our hydrometer readings. Calories are worked out from the gravities. Anything marked estimated is a calculation rather than a measurement.

Brew day

Looking down into the mash: crushed grain and foam in Alan’s white mesh grain bag, inside the kettle
The mash, 2026

Our second all-grain brew, and our second kit from The Homebrew Shop: their Pilsner all-grain mash kit, with 4.7kg of crushed malt in two bags (it weighed 4.808kg on our scales), 40g of bittering hops for the whole boil, 15g of aroma hops for the last ten minutes, a sachet of yeast and a copper finings tablet. Like the IPA’s, the kit doesn’t name its hops, so they’re listed here by their bags. I followed the instructions to the letter. It didn’t save it.

The mash

This time I worked the water out with the Grainfather formulas printed on the kit’s sheet, rather than the shop’s own figures: 16.5L to mash in, from the grain’s weight, and 13.5L to sparge. The mash started at 14:25 at the kit’s 66°C. The temperature wandered a bit, so I gave it an extra ten minutes over the kit’s hour and a half, and it finished at 16:05. Then the sparge, and the first outing for the drilled trug I made after Pilot Episode’s bag leaked wort all over the bench.

The boil-over

With the wort back in the kettle, I set it to boil and went inside. And got distracted. When I came back out to see whether it had reached a rolling boil, the lid’s pressure relief valve was erupting sticky wort all over the garage. I’ll never make that mistake again. I calmly killed the power, took the lid off and cleaned the wort off the sides of the kettle before turning it back on. It was annoying, but I tried my best not to let it put me off, and carried on.

Dark brown wort in the steel kettle after the boil, with the wort chiller’s coil curving down into it
The wort, after the boil, 2026

The boil proper started at 16:55, and Bag C went straight in for the hour. Bag D and the copper finings tablet went in at 17:45, ten minutes from the end (on time, unlike Pilot Episode’s), and the boil finished at 17:55.

I noted 19.5L at the end and put it down to a massive boil-off, forgetting how much wort I’d lost over the side. We put 30 litres of water in and got 19.5 out, and I’ve no idea how much of the missing 10.5 litres was the boil-over and how much was the boil. I really need to measure this kettle’s boil-off.

Fermentation

It started at 1.044, exactly the kit’s estimate. By 27 September fermentation seemed to be finished, so I cold crashed it in the fermentation fridge, at about 5°C (as low as that fridge will go), and left it untouched.

Opening it up

On 7 November I went to bottle it, opened the fermenter, and it was clearly ruined: yeast suspended everywhere, and lumps of mould. It smelled off and tasted foul, so the whole brew went down the drain. The hydrometer read 1.005, so the yeast had got to work before something else did. The end, I guess. But we’ll brew this one again, and next time we’ll make it work.

From start to bottle

  1. 1.044Brew day, 13 September 2026
  2. 1.005Day 55, 7 November 2026: opened to bottle; mouldy and ruined

Recipe

Kit: The Homebrew Shop Pilsner all-grain mash kit

Ingredients for 19.5 litres
IngredientAmountWhen
Crushed malts (Bags A and B)4.808kgMash
Bag C hops40g60 min boil
Bag D hops15g10 min boil
Kit yeast1 sachetPitched
Copper finings tablet1Boil, 10 minutes before the end
Mash
66°C for 100 min
Boil
60 min
Fermentation
Fermenting for 14 days, then cold crash (as cold as the fridge will go) at 5°C for 41 days

Tasting notes

  1. 7 November 2026Ruined. Mouldy, with yeast suspended all the way through it, and it smelled off. It tasted awful: like poison is the only description I can give.

What we’d change

We honestly don’t know what went wrong. Cleaning and sanitising were as careful as ever, and the final gravity says the yeast did its job, so the infection got in somewhere we haven’t found. What we can fix: never walk away from the kettle while it comes up to the boil, and measure how much this kettle boils off in an hour, so the volumes add up and a loss like this one can be explained.

Brew it again?
Yes
Our rating
Fisher & Forbes Brewing Co, home